In New York, an asset must go through probate when it was owned by the deceased person alone, in their own name, with no surviving co-owner and no named beneficiary. Those assets are controlled by the will and pass only after the Surrogate’s Court admits that will and appoints an executor. Almost everything else — jointly held property, accounts with a payable-on-death beneficiary, and assets in a living trust — skips probate and transfers automatically by operation of law or contract.
That one distinction explains most of the confusion families bring into our office. A father leaves a will saying everything goes to his three children equally, but his largest bank account names only one child as the POD beneficiary. The will never touches that account. Understanding what is “in the estate” versus what passes outside it is the first thing you need to settle — and it is frequently the first thing families fight about.
What “Probate” Actually Means in New York
Probate is the court process of proving that a will is valid and giving the named executor legal authority to act. In New York it happens in the Surrogate’s Court of the county where the decedent lived — New York County (Manhattan), Kings (Brooklyn), Queens, Bronx, or Richmond (Staten Island) for City residents. The governing rules come from two statutes you will see referenced throughout any estate matter: the Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL), which sets the substantive rules about who inherits, and the Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act (SCPA), which sets the procedure.
When someone dies with a will, the executor files a probate petition. When someone dies without a will, the process is called administration rather than probate, but the threshold question is identical: which assets are subject to the court’s authority and which are not?
Assets That Must Go Through Probate
The probate estate is made up of property the decedent owned individually with no built-in transfer mechanism. If the only name on the title is the person who died, and no beneficiary or co-owner steps into their shoes automatically, the asset is a probate asset. Common examples include:
- Solely owned real estate. A house or condo titled only in the decedent’s name, with no co-owner holding a right of survivorship.
- Individual bank and brokerage accounts with no payable-on-death or transfer-on-death designation.
- Personal property — cars, jewelry, art, furniture, collectibles, and the contents of the home.
- Business interests held in the decedent’s own name, such as a sole proprietorship or shares in a closely held company with no buy-sell or transfer provision.
- Money owed to the decedent, including unpaid wages, loans they made to others, or a personal-injury claim that survives death.
- Retirement accounts or life insurance with no living beneficiary — if the named beneficiary died first and no contingent was listed, the proceeds typically default to the estate and become probate property.
These are the assets the will actually governs. They cannot be distributed until the Surrogate’s Court issues letters testamentary to the executor (or letters of administration where there is no will). For a fuller walk-through of the filing steps and the different proceedings the court offers, Morgan Legal’s New York office has a useful overview of .
Assets That Skip Probate Entirely
A large share of a typical New Yorker’s wealth never sees the inside of Surrogate’s Court. These “non-probate” assets carry their own instructions and transfer the moment of death, regardless of what the will says.
Jointly Owned Property With Right of Survivorship
When a bank account, brokerage account, or piece of real estate is held by two or more people as joint tenants with right of survivorship — or, for married couples, as tenants by the entirety — the survivor automatically owns the whole thing when one owner dies. The decedent’s interest evaporates; there is nothing for the will to pass. Be careful, though: property held as tenants in common is different. Each owner has a separate, divisible share, and that share does go through probate.
Accounts With Named Beneficiaries
Payable-on-death (POD) bank accounts, transfer-on-death (TOD) brokerage accounts, life insurance policies, IRAs, 401(k)s, and pensions all pass directly to the beneficiary named on the form. This is contract law, not estate law — the financial institution pays whoever is on the designation. The painful lesson families learn over and over is that a beneficiary form beats a will every time. An ex-spouse left on a 401(k) by accident can inherit hundreds of thousands of dollars over the objection of the children named in a perfectly valid will.
Assets in a Revocable Living Trust
Property that was transferred into a revocable living trust during life is owned by the trust, not the individual, so it passes under the trust’s terms without court involvement. Many New Yorkers use a living trust precisely to keep real estate and investment accounts out of probate — and to keep the disposition private, since probate filings are public records. The catch is funding: a trust only avoids probate for assets actually retitled into it. An unfunded trust accomplishes nothing. You can read more about how wills and trusts work together on Morgan Legal’s page.
Other Common Non-Probate Transfers
- Life estates and TOD deeds where a remainder interest passes automatically.
- Gifts completed during the decedent’s lifetime, which are simply no longer part of the estate.
- Certain government and union death benefits paid directly to a designated survivor.
The Spousal Right of Election: A Rule You Cannot Disinherit Around
One New York rule cuts across this whole probate/non-probate divide and surprises a lot of families. Under EPTL 5-1.1-A, a surviving spouse has a right of election to claim a minimum share of the estate even if the will leaves them nothing — generally the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate. Crucially, the calculation reaches beyond the probate estate. New York counts “testamentary substitutes,” meaning many of the non-probate assets above — jointly held property, POD accounts, certain trust assets — are pulled back into the math so a spouse cannot be cut out through clever beneficiary planning. You cannot fully disinherit a husband or wife in New York without their written waiver.
Small Estates: When You Can Skip Full Probate
Not every estate needs a formal proceeding. SCPA Article 13 provides a streamlined voluntary administration — the “small estate” procedure — when the decedent’s personal property (excluding real estate) is worth $50,000 or less. A voluntary administrator files a short affidavit with the Surrogate’s Court and can collect and distribute assets without the full probate machinery. It is faster and cheaper, but it has real limits: it does not cover real property, and it can stall if heirs disagree about who should serve or how assets divide.
Why the Probate/Non-Probate Line Sparks Will Contests
In our practice representing families through will contests, the fight almost always lives at the seam between the will and the beneficiary forms. A few patterns recur:
- Late changes to beneficiary designations. A POD account or life insurance beneficiary is switched weeks before death, often after a new caregiver or relative gains influence. Because that asset bypasses the will, the only way to challenge it may be a separate claim of undue influence or lack of capacity over the designation itself.
- “Convenience” joint accounts. An elderly parent adds one child to a bank account to help pay bills. After death, that child claims the whole account by survivorship while siblings insist it was meant for everyone. New York courts examine the depositor’s actual intent, but proving it is hard and expensive.
- An unfunded or partially funded trust. Assets families assumed were “handled” turn out to still be titled in the decedent’s name — dragging them into probate and into the dispute.
- Spousal claims. A surviving spouse exercises the right of election against an estate that was deliberately steered into non-probate transfers, forcing a recalculation that reduces what the will’s beneficiaries actually receive.
Knowing which bucket each asset falls into tells you where, and how, a dispute can even be raised. A will can be contested in Surrogate’s Court; a beneficiary designation usually requires a different legal theory. If you are weighing whether you have grounds to challenge a will or a transfer, start with our overview of the probate process and the underlying requirements for a valid will.
Don’t Forget the Lifetime Documents
Probate is about what happens after death, but the documents that govern incapacity often shape the estate that is left behind. A New York statutory durable power of attorney under General Obligations Law § 5-1501 lets an agent manage finances while the principal is alive; it ends at death and has no effect on probate. A health care proxy covers medical decisions and likewise expires at death. Where these matter to probate is in the run-up: an agent’s lifetime transfers, gifts, or account changes made under a power of attorney are exactly the transactions that later surface in litigation over what should — or should not — be in the estate.
Putting It Together
If you want to know what your estate — or a loved one’s — will actually put through Surrogate’s Court, walk through every significant asset and ask two questions: Whose name is on it? and Is there a beneficiary or surviving co-owner? Solely owned with no beneficiary means probate. A co-owner with survivorship rights, a named beneficiary, or a funded trust means it skips probate. Then layer the spousal right of election on top, because that rule can reach assets in both categories.
These distinctions decide who inherits, how long the process takes, and where a contest can be fought. Our firm focuses on New York City families navigating exactly these questions — especially when the will and the paperwork point in different directions. For families with property or relatives in Florida as well, our affiliated office handles Florida probate matters. If you have questions about a specific estate, reach out to our probate team for guidance tailored to your situation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a will control all of my assets in New York?
No. A will only controls assets the decedent owned individually with no surviving co-owner and no named beneficiary. Jointly held property with survivorship rights, payable-on-death and transfer-on-death accounts, life insurance, retirement accounts with living beneficiaries, and assets in a funded living trust all pass outside the will, no matter what the will says.
Can I avoid probate entirely in New York?
You can avoid probate for specific assets by using joint ownership with right of survivorship, beneficiary designations, or a properly funded revocable living trust. But the spousal right of election under EPTL 5-1.1-A still reaches many of these transfers, and any asset left solely in your name with no beneficiary will go through Surrogate’s Court.
What is the small estate process in New York?
SCPA Article 13 allows voluntary administration when the decedent’s personal property is worth $50,000 or less. A voluntary administrator files a short affidavit with the Surrogate’s Court and collects assets without full probate. It does not cover real estate and can stall if heirs disagree.
Can a beneficiary designation be challenged like a will?
Beneficiary designations pass by contract and bypass the will, so they cannot simply be contested in the same probate proceeding. Challenging one usually requires a separate claim, such as undue influence or lack of capacity affecting the designation itself, which is often more difficult to prove.
How does the spousal right of election affect probate in New York?
Under EPTL 5-1.1-A, a surviving spouse can claim the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate, even if the will leaves them nothing. The calculation includes testamentary substitutes such as joint accounts and POD assets, so it can reduce what the will’s beneficiaries actually receive.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.